As Employers Turn to Evidence-Based Hiring, How Can Libraries Prepare Job Seekers? | Higher Ground
We’ve been hiring people for jobs the same way since the 19th century—job ad, resume, interview. The medium has changed, and almost all of this is now conducted online (although I applied for one job in 2011 at a technical college that required a paper application and hard copies of my transcripts). But the basic technology of notifying people of employment needs and identifying potential candidates to fill those needs persists.
As tolerance for the risk of a poor employee fit decreases under market pressures and thin margins, employers are starting to realize that their previous proxies—degrees, keywords, a few hours of conversation, and limited reference checks—are creating a dual problem: there are too many of the wrong applicants for open positions.
Employers’ main focus is getting their work needs met. They need to answer two seemingly simple questions. First, does this applicant have the skills to do the job I need done? Second, will this applicant be a good colleague? How can they accomplish this more effectively?
On the other side of the equation are people looking for work. Everyone brings a bevy of experiences that have helped them learn skills, not all of which they have developed through formal education. In fact, most of the critical “core” people skills aren’t taught or certified at all. How do you capture “critical thinking” and “entrepreneurial mindset” on a resume? How can job seekers more effectively convey what they will actually bring to a job?
Employers are increasingly turning to evidence-based hiring—using an array of non-cognitive assessments to learn more about job applicants and determine through real-work scenarios how they respond to situations. Evidence-based hiring isn’t new. When I was interviewing for elementary school teaching jobs more than 15 years ago, teaching a demonstration lesson was part of the interview process, but it’s gaining more attention now as employers seek better insight into prospective hires’ skills and non-cognitive attributes. The goal is to increase candidate pool diversity and identify prospective employees who might otherwise be filtered out. At the same time, using skills-based evidence to make hiring decisions also improves the quality of candidates and helps to ensure a better job fit, leading to longer retention and happier workplaces.
Assessments are becoming more sophisticated. As evidence-based hiring expands, validation becomes easier (check out CoreScore, WorkFORCE Assessments, and Pairin, for example). The challenge lies in the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) openness to accepting on-degree based assessments as valid, non-discriminatory practices. While evidence-based hiring is becoming standard hiring practice in other industrialized countries around the world, the EEOC has shown a persistent reluctance to allow deviation from the old models of hiring—even though the way we’ve approached hiring in the past has actually served to cement discrimination and inequality.
Nevertheless, evidence-based hiring is beginning to take root in healthcare and manufacturing, as well as in technology. It is changing the way employers think about their workforce and the tasks associated with jobs. It is changing the way job training programs prepare their participants. No longer does it make sense to train people for a specific job. Evidence-based hiring opens up a network of related jobs with shared skill sets. Transferable skills have never been more important.
For the first time since the invention of help wanted ads, evidence-based hiring is in fact disrupting the way we train, seek, and hire people to do work. But how can libraries play a part? Talking with patrons about skills and job families may help refine their thinking about their job search process and expand the range of opportunities.
Closer to home, what do you think is the evidence that someone will be a good librarian? What are the skills and qualities you look for when you hire? How do you know that you’ve found someone who will be a good fit? Could you prove it? What would be a useful assessment of non-cognitive skills to succeed as a librarian?
This article was featured in our free Extra Helping enewsletter.
Subscribe today to have more articles like this delivered to you twice a week.
This article is reprinted by permission from